Q&A: Tilapia vs Red Snapper Fish: Why our Multi Collagen Products use Both

UPDATED LAST ON:

March 30, 2021

TOPICS:

Collagen College Summary Icon

Quick Summary

It’s not uncommon for a supplement company to use different sources for different products. We’re no different. We use only the best wild caught fish, including both tilapia and red snapper. To be the first and only multi collagen NSF Certified for Sport®, we needed these certified products to source from tilapia. Our non-NSF products use red snapper. Both fish sources (yes, even tilapia that has a bad reputation) ensures our multi collagen products offer premium quality and diversity.

Question

I noticed your unflavored multi collagen, that’s now NSF certified, uses the fish tilapia instead of red snapper. Why did you change?TJ

Thanks for the great question TJ! We love when customers read labels (especially ours) and don’t hesitate to ask us for clarity.

The super-short answer is that if we wanted our multi collagen to be NSF Certified, the certification process required us to shift our fish source from wild caught red snapper to wild caught tilapia.

The decision driver: NSF Certification

Let’s start with the why, thanks Simon Sinek.

Aside from wanting to help anybody and everybody live healthier and fuller lives, we also strive to be the #1 supplement trusted by professional athletes and Olympians.

To sell to Olympians, the NHL, MLB, and many other professional sports leagues, a supplement MUST be NSF Certified for Sport®. Simple enough, right?

Which of our multi collagen products use Tilapia vs Red Snapper?

Wild Caught Fish Sources for CB Supplements Multi Collagen Comparison

If you’re into reading ingredients (which you should be — especially with supplements), you’ll notice that our NSF certified products (currently just our unflavored multi collagen), will use wild caught tilapia fish instead of wild caught red snapper fish.

Our NSF certified Unflavored uses Wild Caught Tilapia:

Unflavored Multi Collagen Label using Tilapia Fish

If you continue to read labels on our other products, you’ll notice that our flavored multi collagen powder will use wild caught red snapper as the fish source. Those flavors are:

Our Non-NSF certified flavors use Wild Caught Red Snapper:

Chocolate Multi Collagen label using Red Snapper fish

Does NSF certification require Tilapia fish?

It’s not that the NSF certification process requires tilapia fish over red snapper fish — it’s fairly fish agnostic (unless we wanted to use goldfish or something 🐠).

This is about manufacturing.

To produce a premium grade product, our manufacturer must be US-based and the facility has GMP (Good Manufacturing Practice) — see what the FDA says about GMP. Every single producer of an ingredient in our multi collagen complex blend has to pass NSF Certification. This is the HARDEST certification for a manufacturer to achieve. And many manufacturers simply choose not to deal with it — trust us, we’ve done our research.

Are there some manufacturers, that we didn’t connect with, willing to use red snapper in an NSF supplement? Maybe. But we talked to quite a few!

We are the first and only multi collagen to be NSF Certified. It’s the cleanest multi collagen powder you can find. To achieve this level of quality, wild caught tilapia needed to be our fish source.

A Few Pros of Tilapia vs Red Snapper in a Multi Collagen

Some Pros of Tilapia vs Red Snapper in Multi Collagen Powder

Though all our products are premium grade and we work really hard to perfect the multi collagen complex on all of them, we have discovered some slight pros of using wild caught tilapia over wild caught red snapper.

Note: most people won’t and can’t tell the difference between using different fish sources. Remember, we’re our own worst critic in all of this!

  1. Taste. We tasted aprx. 15 different batches of our multi collagen complex and tilapia seemed to have a slightly less fishy taste than red snapper. Tilapia is generally a less “fishy” fish than red snapper.
  2. Consistency. We noticed a slightly better dissolvability with Tilapia (again, most people probably won’t recognize the difference — all our multi collagen products dissolve extremely well!)

Where we source our Tilapia Fish for our multi collagen

Farm Raised Tilapia in Pens
Definitely NOT here.

As you’ve noticed, we’ve mentioned numerous times that our Tilapia is WILD CAUGHT.

Isn’t wild caught Tilapia hard to source?

Yes, wild caught tilapia can be difficult to source! That’s why the NSF certification process is complex, long, and difficult — only premium ingredients will pass their testing!

Tilapia suffers from a bad reputation because 73% of tilapia imported to the United States from China is farm-raised and fed absolute SLOP (we’re talking animal feces here people!) As you probably assumed, that is not the type of Tilapia we use in our multi collagen. We source our wild caught Tilapia in the USA — which is the top 10% of high-quality tilapia!

Advocating for Tilapia

For all your Tilapia haters, here are some quick facts you may not know:

  • Yes, tilapia is a real fish — it has scales and bones. We get our collagen from the bones and skin.
  • Tilapia is a freshwater fish that lives in natural habitats.
  • Tilapia is a high-quality fish low in metals and high in protein content.
  • Tilapia has more omega-3 fats than red snapper (which doesn’t mean anything to our supplement, but an interesting fact!)

Is Tilapia a better fish source (since the end product is NSF certified) than Red Snapper?

CB Supplements Multi Collagen Products
The First & Only Multi Collagen NSF Certified for Sport®

Since NSF certification tests for over 270+ substances and ensures there are no unsafe levels of contaminants, could our NSF products (that use Tilapia) be considered superior to our non-NSF products (that use Red Snapper)?

Well, yea, of course. NSF certified supplements will always be superior from end-to-end. That’s why Olympians and professional athletes require NSF certification!

However, that doesn’t translate into Tilapia being a better fish source than Red Snapper. Both are fantastic fish sources to ensure our multi collagen products provide awesome collagen benefits to our loyal customers. We are committed to a premium product — it’s a founding pillar.

This is simply a pivot to ensure the ecosystem of CB Supplements could operate in the way we needed it, to align with our why (be the #1 supplement trusted by professional athletes and Olympians).

Final Thoughts

Being the first and only multi collagen to be NSF Certified for Sport® means there’s no existing prototype here for us to follow. When you’re sourcing from multiple animals (cows, chickens, fish) to provide a supplement with 5 types of collagen, there’s a balancing act amongst many variables (sourcing, manufacturing, certification, timing, etc.).

However, if you have any further questions about our fish sources, we’d be happy to continue this discussion. Use our chat to send a message or Contact Us.

More Helpful Resources

Collagen College Logo White

This Collagen College™ article created by:

Author

Eric Sharp CMO

Eric Sharp

Eric discovered collagen back in 2019 (thanks to Charlie) and been a believer since. He brings 20+ years of digital marketing experience to the CB Supplements team. As CMO, he's directly responsible for crafting the CB Supplements positioning, content, branding, and overall marketing direction.

Contributors

Charlie Bailes - Founder CB Supplements

Charlie Bailes

If you've bought our multi collagen, there's a pretty darn good chance you've received an awesome personalized thank you note from Charlie. Aside from caring A LOT about customer appreciation, he's also our Founder and CEO and responsible for assembling our great team and vision.

Collagen College Logo

New to collagen? Looking to buy a collagen supplement? Ready to up your existing collagen game? (Oh, we can help!)

Wherever you fall on the spectrum of collagen love, we got you.

From the history of collagen to how to take collagen powder — our goal is to be the source for accurate and fun collagen info.

CB Supplements Multi Collagen Powder Products
The only supplement endorsed by NY Times Best Selling Author, Dr. Cate M.D.

FREE SHIPPING over $69!
Scroll to Top